Class: AnalysisVerdict

pondie's verdict on one analysis of the parse a revision revises, reached while extracting the whole record. The verdict overrides the original's proposal, grouping and role alike.

What a verdict does to what is stored against the analysis -- claims, their evidence, and users' votes on them:

- accept, relabel: nothing moves. The key is unchanged, so everything stored against

_ it applies to the revision as it stands._

- edit: everything is copied to the one analysis in replaced_by, whose points are

_ the corrected ones._

- split: everything is copied to each analysis in replaced_by. - merge: everything stored against each merged analysis is copied to the one

_ analysis they merge into. Two copies of the same field with the same value become_

_ one claim; with different values they stay competing claims, resolved like any_

_ other._

- omit: nothing is copied. - add: nothing to copy; the analysis is new.

Every copy records the key and parse it was copied from, so a reviewer can tell a copied claim from one made against the revision. The revised parse and everything stored against it are kept, unchanged, as history: superseded rather than deleted, and left out of projections and studysets.

URI: parse:AnalysisVerdict

 classDiagram
    class AnalysisVerdict
    click AnalysisVerdict href "../AnalysisVerdict/"
      AnalysisVerdict : evidence





        AnalysisVerdict --> "*" TextSpan : evidence
        click TextSpan href "../TextSpan/"



      AnalysisVerdict : key

      AnalysisVerdict : reason

      AnalysisVerdict : replaced_by

      AnalysisVerdict : role

      AnalysisVerdict : verdict





        AnalysisVerdict --> "1" AuditVerdict : verdict
        click AuditVerdict href "../AuditVerdict/"

Slots

Name	Cardinality and Range	Description	Inheritance
key	1 String	The revised parse's analysis key; for add, the new analysis's key in this r...	direct
verdict	1 AuditVerdict		direct
replaced_by	* String	The keys in this revision that take the analysis's place: itself for accept a...	direct
role	0..1 String or  CoordinateRole	For relabel, the role the points have instead	direct
reason	1 String		direct
evidence	* TextSpan	The sentences of the paper the verdict rests on	direct

Usages

used by	used in	type	used
CoordinateParse	verdicts	range	AnalysisVerdict

Identifier and Mapping Information

Schema Source

• from schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse

Mappings

Mapping Type	Mapped Value
self	parse:AnalysisVerdict
native	parse:AnalysisVerdict

LinkML Source

Direct

name: AnalysisVerdict
description: "pondie's verdict on one analysis of the parse a revision revises, reached\
  \ while extracting the whole record. The verdict overrides the original's proposal,\
  \ grouping and role alike.\nWhat a verdict does to what is stored against the analysis\
  \ -- claims, their evidence, and users' votes on them:\n- accept, relabel: nothing\
  \ moves. The key is unchanged, so everything stored against\n  it applies to the\
  \ revision as it stands.\n- edit: everything is copied to the one analysis in `replaced_by`,\
  \ whose points are\n  the corrected ones.\n- split: everything is copied to each\
  \ analysis in `replaced_by`. - merge: everything stored against each merged analysis\
  \ is copied to the one\n  analysis they merge into. Two copies of the same field\
  \ with the same value become\n  one claim; with different values they stay competing\
  \ claims, resolved like any\n  other.\n- omit: nothing is copied. - add: nothing\
  \ to copy; the analysis is new.\nEvery copy records the key and parse it was copied\
  \ from, so a reviewer can tell a copied claim from one made against the revision.\
  \ The revised parse and everything stored against it are kept, unchanged, as history:\
  \ superseded rather than deleted, and left out of projections and studysets."
from_schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse
rank: 1000
attributes:
  key:
    name: key
    description: The revised parse's analysis key; for `add`, the new analysis's key
      in this revision.
    from_schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse/coordinates
    domain_of:
    - ParsedAnalysis
    - AnalysisVerdict
    range: string
    required: true
  verdict:
    name: verdict
    from_schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse/coordinates
    rank: 1000
    domain_of:
    - AnalysisVerdict
    range: AuditVerdict
    required: true
  replaced_by:
    name: replaced_by
    description: 'The keys in this revision that take the analysis''s place: itself
      for accept and relabel, the one corrected analysis for edit, the replacements
      for split and merge, none for omit.'
    from_schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse/coordinates
    rank: 1000
    domain_of:
    - AnalysisVerdict
    range: string
    multivalued: true
  role:
    name: role
    description: For relabel, the role the points have instead.
    from_schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse/coordinates
    domain_of:
    - ParsedAnalysis
    - AnalysisVerdict
    any_of:
    - range: CoordinateRole
    - range: string
  reason:
    name: reason
    from_schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse/coordinates
    domain_of:
    - TableReading
    - OmittedAnalysis
    - AnalysisVerdict
    range: string
    required: true
  evidence:
    name: evidence
    description: The sentences of the paper the verdict rests on.
    from_schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse/coordinates
    rank: 1000
    domain_of:
    - AnalysisVerdict
    range: TextSpan
    multivalued: true
    inlined_as_list: true

Induced

name: AnalysisVerdict
description: "pondie's verdict on one analysis of the parse a revision revises, reached\
  \ while extracting the whole record. The verdict overrides the original's proposal,\
  \ grouping and role alike.\nWhat a verdict does to what is stored against the analysis\
  \ -- claims, their evidence, and users' votes on them:\n- accept, relabel: nothing\
  \ moves. The key is unchanged, so everything stored against\n  it applies to the\
  \ revision as it stands.\n- edit: everything is copied to the one analysis in `replaced_by`,\
  \ whose points are\n  the corrected ones.\n- split: everything is copied to each\
  \ analysis in `replaced_by`. - merge: everything stored against each merged analysis\
  \ is copied to the one\n  analysis they merge into. Two copies of the same field\
  \ with the same value become\n  one claim; with different values they stay competing\
  \ claims, resolved like any\n  other.\n- omit: nothing is copied. - add: nothing\
  \ to copy; the analysis is new.\nEvery copy records the key and parse it was copied\
  \ from, so a reviewer can tell a copied claim from one made against the revision.\
  \ The revised parse and everything stored against it are kept, unchanged, as history:\
  \ superseded rather than deleted, and left out of projections and studysets."
from_schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse
rank: 1000
attributes:
  key:
    name: key
    description: The revised parse's analysis key; for `add`, the new analysis's key
      in this revision.
    from_schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse/coordinates
    owner: AnalysisVerdict
    domain_of:
    - ParsedAnalysis
    - AnalysisVerdict
    range: string
    required: true
  verdict:
    name: verdict
    from_schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse/coordinates
    rank: 1000
    owner: AnalysisVerdict
    domain_of:
    - AnalysisVerdict
    range: AuditVerdict
    required: true
  replaced_by:
    name: replaced_by
    description: 'The keys in this revision that take the analysis''s place: itself
      for accept and relabel, the one corrected analysis for edit, the replacements
      for split and merge, none for omit.'
    from_schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse/coordinates
    rank: 1000
    owner: AnalysisVerdict
    domain_of:
    - AnalysisVerdict
    range: string
    multivalued: true
  role:
    name: role
    description: For relabel, the role the points have instead.
    from_schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse/coordinates
    owner: AnalysisVerdict
    domain_of:
    - ParsedAnalysis
    - AnalysisVerdict
    range: string
    any_of:
    - range: CoordinateRole
    - range: string
  reason:
    name: reason
    from_schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse/coordinates
    owner: AnalysisVerdict
    domain_of:
    - TableReading
    - OmittedAnalysis
    - AnalysisVerdict
    range: string
    required: true
  evidence:
    name: evidence
    description: The sentences of the paper the verdict rests on.
    from_schema: https://neurostuff.org/schemas/neuroimaging-paper-parse/coordinates
    rank: 1000
    owner: AnalysisVerdict
    domain_of:
    - AnalysisVerdict
    range: TextSpan
    multivalued: true
    inlined: true
    inlined_as_list: true